There are three useful ways to take a Werewolf or Mafia-style night online: have a moderator run it over a call, use a dedicated game to manage roles, or choose a social-deduction game with movement and tasks.
The right choice depends on whether your group enjoys conversation alone or wants something to do between accusations.
Run a moderated game over a call
For a simple hosted version, nominate one person to moderate rather than play a hidden role. They privately assign teams, announce the current phase, collect private night choices, and run the group's vote.
Choose one published ruleset and tell players which edition you are using. Avoid improvising several special roles in the first session: the moderator needs to resolve conflicting actions consistently.
This approach is useful when everybody already has a call app and nobody wants to learn movement controls. Its cost is organizational effort. Check that private messages really stay private and that every player understands when to speak.
Let a dedicated game manage the rules
A game such as Town of Salem packages hidden roles and phase-based deduction into a dedicated experience. This can suit people who enjoy studying role interactions rather than asking a friend to operate the entire round.
Check the particular version and platform before promising browser access. The Steam edition linked below is an installed game. Similar names, sequels, and older articles can refer to different products.
A larger role catalog is not automatically a better first night. It can give experienced players more to discuss while creating more questions for newcomers.
Add movement and observable actions
Banana Society takes the hidden-team idea into a shared jungle. Citizens gather bananas; Eaters secretly eat and interfere. The group gets evidence from interactions before it meets to vote.
Each person plays in a desktop browser, and the game handles the simulation. You still benefit from somebody organizing the lobby, but a human moderator does not have to resolve every action.
Choose it when your friends want a game to move around in between discussions. Choose a traditional call-based game when movement and collection would distract from the conversation your group enjoys.
Match the format to the group
| Format | Who runs the round? | What fills the time between votes? |
|---|---|---|
| Moderated Werewolf/Mafia | A designated person using agreed rules. | Conversation and privately submitted actions. |
| Dedicated hidden-role software | The game's rules and interface. | Role-specific actions, reading, and deduction. |
| Banana Society | The game itself; a host organizes the lobby. | Moving, collecting, eating, and observing in The Grove. |
The distinction matters more than whether all three are called “social deduction.” A group looking for a relaxed call and a group looking for active play may prefer different formats.
Keep the first explanation small
Explain the teams, the objective, and how a vote works before listing exceptions. Give people a chance to ask questions privately if their role is hidden.
In Banana Society, start with how to play. For a more general introduction, read what social deduction means.
Sources and review notes
Reviewed September 6, 2026. Consult Ultimate Werewolf's publisher for that game's ruleset and Town of Salem's publisher listing for that specific product. The call-based format above is a hosting suggestion; Banana Society is a separate game, not an official Werewolf or Mafia adaptation.
Meet us in The Grove.
Free browser play. Bring your friends, or learn the controls with bots.
Play free